Бывший недостаток стал преимуществом: почему переборквалификацию теперь ценят работодатели

Tammy Homegardner is a career coach, LinkedIn expert, author and founder of The Job Search School. A client emailed me last month because she had received another rejection. Same message every time: “We decided to move forward with another candidate.” She was a director with 15 years of experience, but she was applying for manager roles. In her email, she asked: “They keep saying I’m overqualified. But the pay is fine. I want the role. Why won’t anyone hire me?” I told her something that surprised her. Being overqualified is no longer a liability. It’s become an advantage. But only if you understand what hiring managers are actually afraid of. The market is shifting in your favor. For years, I saw hiring managers avoid overqualified candidates. But they weren’t worried job seekers would leave for something better. They were worried about something else entirely. They were worried candidates couldn’t find a job at their level anymore and were taking the role as a fallback while they kept looking. That’s changing. According to a 2025 survey from Express Employment Professionals and The Harris Poll, 70% of U.S. hiring managers now say their company considers overqualified candidates. That’s not a small shift. That’s a fundamental change in how many companies think about hiring. Why the change? The data tells the story: “50% believe they have more confidence on the job. 48% say they’re more productive. 47% cite better decision-making skills. 46% value their ability to mentor junior employees. 45% appreciate that they require little to no training.” Employers have figured out that experienced people get more done. And they’ve stopped assuming that experience means you’re trapped and resentful. This is what hiring managers are really thinking. Here’s what’s actually running through a hiring manager’s head when they see an overqualified application. They’re not thinking you’re too good for the role. They’re thinking: “This person couldn’t find a job at their level. They’re settling. They’ll take this job and keep looking the entire time they’re here. Their attention will be divided. They’ll resent the work. And they’ll leave the moment something better comes along.” That anxiety is real: Seventy-five percent of hiring managers think overqualified hires in lower-level roles will have a hard time staying motivated. Seventy-four percent worry they’ll leave at the first better opportunity. Nearly 60% would prefer training a new hire than risk hiring someone who’s mentally already looking elsewhere. This is the real problem. Not that you’re overqualified. But that hiring managers believe you’re there by default, not by choice. They think you didn’t get what you wanted, so you’re settling. And they don’t trust people who settle. Show you’re here by choice, not desperation. Most overqualified candidates fail because they hope the resume speaks for itself. Instead, they need to address the real concern directly in their application materials. Not defensively. Just clearly. You need to show that you’re not here because you couldn’t find anything else. You’re here because you actually want this. In your cover letter, try this: “I understand this role represents a step down from my previous position. I’m specifically seeking this hands-on work because I miss the operational side of the business. I’m drawn to this company because of how you approach [something specific about the company]. I’m ready to focus on delivery and impact rather than management complexity.” You’re doing something critical. You’re telling them that you made a choice. You didn’t fall into this role because your options ran out. You selected it. That changes everything. Another version addresses what they’re really afraid of: “I’m not taking a step down. I’m taking a different path. After 15 years managing teams, I realized I want to get back to the work itself. Your role lets me do that while contributing at a level that matches my experience. That’s what I’m actually looking for right now.” That’s not weakness. That’s clarity about what you want. Hiring managers don’t distrust clarity. They distrust people who seem like they’re just passing through. In the interview, prove your commitment. Once you get the interview, prove you’re serious. If they ask about being overqualified, lean in. “I’m not concerned. I chose this role intentionally. I want to do this work and be part of this team. My experience means I’ll be productive immediately and can help develop others, but I’m here because I want to be here.” You need to ask specific questions about the company, the team and the challenges they’re facing. Show you’ve thought about this. Show them you’re not just marking time until something better comes along. Throughout the interview, signal that you understand their hesitation and you’ve already resolved it for yourself. You’re not asking them to take a chance on you. You’re telling them you’ve already decided about this role. This is the bigger picture. Being overqualified used to mean you were desperate. Now it can mean you’re intentional. While more employers now consider overqualified candidates, getting them to actually hire you depends on one thing: positioning yourself as choosing them consciously, not defaulting to them because you ran out of options. Your experience is not your problem. Your refusal to be honest about why you want this role is. Address it directly. Tell them you made a choice. Show them you understand their concern and have already thought through whether this is actually the right move for you. That’s how being overqualified becomes your biggest asset: It gives you the power to make intentional choices. Use it. Forbes Coaches Council is an invitation-only community for leading business and career coaches. Do I qualify?