Ганс-Херманн Хоппе: государство — главный паразит, а выход лежит в секцессии и золоте

Key Takeaways: The author, summarizing a CdK podcast with Hans-Hermann Hoppe, traces Hoppe from 1960s West German Marxism through East German decay to Mises and Rothbard: no private property, no functioning economy. Even a “night-watchman” state is treated as unstable—like a little heroin. Political prescription: many small jurisdictions (Liechtenstein, Swiss cantons) so people vote with their feet; Brussels-style centralization is the opposite. Money printing, welfare and debt are called Ponzi schemes that break when births fall; mass immigration cannot replace high-trust capital. Gold is offered as money the state cannot inflate. Geopolitics: U.S. bases and far wars (Ukraine, Middle East; the author cites Venezuela and an Iran school strike as examples of a shifted “acceptable” bar) fail a reciprocity test. Drones change war; conscription is called yesterday’s tool. Democracy, in this view, multiplies extractors. Exit path: secession, competition, private property—not better rulers. I have long admired Hans-Hermann Hoppe and closely followed his work for over a decade, as in my view, his is one of the most uncompromising, intellectually courageous and rigorous voices in the Austrian tradition. A few days ago I came across a  wide-ranging conversation  he gave on the Portuguese podcast CdK and at a time when Western societies appear increasingly trapped in cycles of debt, demographic decline, geopolitical overreach and institutional decay, every word of it felt not merely relevant but urgent. What follows is a distillation of the points that struck me as most pertinent to the challenges we face today. Hoppe’s own intellectual journey, from the Marxist milieu of 1960s West Germany to radical anarcho-capitalism, was shaped by direct observation of socialism’s failure during visits in East Germany. The absence of private property rights produced nothing but decay that could be seen everywhere in the daily life of those unfortunate enough to be trapped in this system: neglected buildings and derelict infrastructure, chronic shortages, abject poverty for the many and luxury for the few, and economic dysfunction on all levels that no amount of central planning could remedy. This early disillusionment led him, via Friedman and Hayek, to Mises and finally to Rothbard, who became his mentor.  Along the way, he discarded every residual concession to the state. Even the idea of minarchism, the concept of a “minimal state”, where the government’s only role is protecting people from force, theft, fraud, and breach of contract, proved, in his view, an unstable halfway house. After all, you cannot have “a little bit” of state power, much like you cannot have a little bit of heroin. Or rather, you can, but in both scenarios you will end up having a lot more than you planned and both scenarios will have a very predictable dénouement.  The political implications for contemporary Europe are immediate. Hoppe holds up Liechtenstein as the closest existing approximation to his ideal: a tiny jurisdiction whose ruler lives largely from his own resources, whose villages retain the formal right to secede, and whose very smallness disciplines the authorities. Imagine, he suggests, a Europe of a thousand Liechtensteins instead of the relentless, forced and unnatural conformity pursued by Brussels. Competition between jurisdictions would constrain taxation and regulation far more effectively than any constitutional parchment. Switzerland’s cantonal system is a great example of this, as the competitive pressure and the freedom that citizens have to “vote with their feet” keeps state power and taxation in check.  That doesn’t mean that Switzerland is some kind of heaven on earth, of course. As I have repeatedly warned against, and as Hoppe also points out in this interview, even here, the drift toward centralization might be slow but it is steady.  Some politicians at the federal level actively push for closer alignment or even membership in the EU, not because it would benefit ordinary citizens, but because it serves their own interests. The incentives of tax-funded politicians, Hoppe observes, are inherently toward centralization and the enlargement of the very apparatus that pays them. Nowhere is the parasitic nature of the modern state clearer than in monetary and fiscal policy. The power to print money, Hoppe notes, is the surest way for governments to “make friends.” Welfare reforms and wealth transfer programs are literally Ponzi schemes built on the assumption of perpetual population growth and rising productivity. When birth rates collapse and native populations age, the arithmetic behind the scam breaks down. Mass immigration is then presented as the technocratic solution, yet it cannot substitute for the cultural and social capital that underpins a high-trust, high-productivity society. Debt is simply pushed onto future generations who never consented to it. Keynesian prescriptions that celebrate consumption and deficit spending only accelerate this process, while universities continue to mass-produce students that are economically illiterate enough to embrace these ideas. And the vicious circle goes on and on, until there is no wealth left to steal and redistribute.  Geopolitically, Hoppe is equally unsparing. The United States maintains roughly eight hundred military bases around the world and has repeatedly intervened in conflicts that have little to do with genuine self-defense. This attitude, however, has become so normalized that it’s easy to forget how absolutely abnormal it is. One only has to look at recent events to see how far the threshold of what is considered acceptable has shifted. The global reaction to the US invading Venezuela and kidnapping its leader, for instance, was surreally muted. Or when it just bombed a school in Iran, killed over a hundred children under the age of 12, and started a war that has been going on for over 6 months and has claimed thousands more lives so far; not to mention the catastrophic impact it had on the global energy supply.  Hoppe himself offers a simple thought experiment that exposes this double standard. Just imagine a scenario where any other country behaved the way the US does and the response that would trigger. What if European nations had military bases spread all over the US? Or how would Washington react if China stationed missiles in Mexico? The same logic that condemns such a move should apply to NATO’s eastward expansion and the prolonged proxy conflict in Ukraine. On the Middle East he is equally skeptical of open-ended commitments. Technology has altered the calculus of war: drones and precision weapons have reduced the traditional advantages of large conventional forces, yet Western governments continue to prepare for earlier forms of conflict, including the possible return of conscription. Against this backdrop of military conflict, fiscal predation, demographic imbalance and imperial overstretch, Hoppe returns to the fundamentals of sound money. Gold is real money, that cannot be inflated at will by political authorities. It restores the possibility of genuine saving, capital accumulation, and independence from the state and its parasitic institutions, and it allows people to escape the forced consumption loop and the speculation encouraged by permanently negative real interest rates. It also offers a way out from all the attacks on individual financial sovereignty and all the predictable attempts by the state to close the remaining escape valves. Throughout this conversation Hoppe confirms a simple diagnosis: the state is the greatest parasite in history. Politicians and their clientele live by extracting resources from productive citizens and the democratic mechanism does not solve this problem, but it merely broadens the circle of those who can claim a share of the spoils. Instead of a single monarch, we now have many smaller ones. The alternative is not a better set of rulers, but the progressive dismantling of the monopoly itself through secession, competition and the reassertion of private property in every domain.